by onegreyghost » Fri Apr 03, 2015 1:09 pm
I will do the best that I can to provide an unbiased review of the Beta and Sherco. Some background first. I have three to four riding friends that ride every week, we put about 3000miles a year on a dirtbike and have rode every brand availabe. We have doing this for 30 years and 90% of the riding we do is single track. We ride 5-7 enduros a year. The numbers are straight from the manual. Beta weight 104kg, seat height 930mm, ground clearance 320mm, pegs clearance 407mm, fuel capacity 9.5l. Sherco weight couldn't find it in the manual, seat height 970mm, ground clearance 350mm, peg clearance couldn't find it but feels higher than beta, fuel capacity 9.5l. Both bikes are very well engineered and the fit and finish is as good as anything available. The motors are very similar on how they make and deliver power but the Sherco seems smother almost electric like maybe that is due to such a large fly wheel weight and electronic power valve. Both have dual map switches that you can feel the difference however the sherco is very noticable, the importer says its a 7 hp difference. Neither motors have boiled an ounce of coolant and seem bullet proof. The beta is easier to tune the power characteristics with the manual adjustable power valve. This would come in handy dialing in the power for different types of riding conditions. The ergonomics of the sherco is super slinder and transitions easier in single track conditions. Both are rock steady pinned in 6 th gear. I have riden KTM's for years and was very skeptical of going back to WP but was blown away of how good it really works. I am not sure what Sherco requested but its way better than any KTM set up. The suspension and handling is the biggest difference between the two bikes. To me this is where the Sherco really begins to shine, the tougher and nastier the conditions the better it responds. Its very effortless to maneuver between trees and over trail trash. The front end sticks like glue to the ground allowing me to put more confidence in the front and worry about it slipping and tucking. The beta on the other hand I really struggled with the turning and never had any confidence in the front end. Seems like it wanted to cross rut and tuck constantly. Like I said earlier we put about 3000 miles on a bike a year and I sold the beta and it had less than 500. Again this is my experience while others are winning races on them I just never got comfortable. My suggestion would be to demo ride both in the area that you mostly like to ride and then choose but for me I will purchase another Sherco I believe they are that good for the conditions we like to ride. I hope this helps and let me know if you would like to hear more specifics.